Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Warlord : Series 4. Issue #1 Through #4



Confession time.

Despite being a big fan of sword and sorcery comics and Mike Grell's writing, I have yet to read a single issue of the first series of Warlord. Indeed, the first issue of this - the fourth Warlord Series - marked the first time I ever opened up any Warlord book Mike Grell had written. I have no excuse for this, save that all of the many classic series I have meant to pick up "some day" fell by the wayside when I started tracking down all the parts of my collection I had to sell off during the years spent trying to find a real job after getting my librarian degree.

(In the interest of full disclosure, I should note that I did read the first issue of Bruce Jones' attempt to revive Warlord a few years ago and the less said about that book, the better.)

I mention all this to so that I can further explain the rather unique perspective that I have upon Warlord. Because while I am broadly familiar with the character of Travis Morgan, his companions and Skartaris from the Green Arrow series, I have found out, in reading more about the series, how woefully ignorant I am regarding the exact details and unique history of the characters.

Case in point; I made mention of Travis Morgan's bard Tinder in my review of the second issue of this series. I took an immediate liking to the character, having a fondness for bards when I play Dungeons and Dragons and Tinder being a prime example of one who does not fit the tights-wearing, lute-strumming buffoon stereotype most people associate with the word "bard". I didn't know until I started doing some research into the first series that Tinder is the long lost son of Travis Morgan and his queen Tara but that both parents (and possibly Tinder himself) are ignorant of their relation to one another.







This marks the one flaw I see in the writing of this series; Grell seems to assume some passing familiarity with the characters right at the gate. Grell does not fully explain who Travis Morgan is and how he came to be Warlord of a city in a mystical land until the second issue. This is potentially fatal in these days when some readers are increasingly reluctant to give even a new TV series a shot past the first episode, even in a series which is reknowned for being mysterious.

Still, it is a credit to Grell's writing that he can create a fantasy story that is engaging to those even those readers who have no desire to dig into the mythology of an established series once exposed to it. Every issue thus far is written in such a manner that even if we do not know the full history of what has come before, we can still enjoy the action put before us now. I won't say it wasn't a little confusing getting a handle on things at first. But the third issue gave us enough action to keep things interesting and the fourth issue gave us some much needed clarification as the two seemingly independent story-lines met up.

For those who are as confused as I was, here's a quick summation of the action and players thus far.


An paleontologist named Alysha finds a perfectly preserved dinosaur body frozen in an icy cave in Tibet. She takes a sample of her discovery to Dr. Kate Archer, another paleontologist who confirms her findings. Together they go to Ned Hawkins - a daredevil playboy millionaire - who agrees to finance an expedition to Tibet. Hawkins comes along on the expedition along with Ewan McBane - a filmmaker Hawkins want to film their findings.

They manage to find the cave but are quickly attacked by the Chinese soldiers, who have set up camp near the cave. The resulting fire-fight traps the party in the cave, where they discover a glowing portal.







Cut to Skartaris and the city of Shamballah, where refugees from the nearby nation of Kiro are arriving in great numbers. Travis Morgan, Warlord of Shamballah and his wife, Queen Tara, talk with the refugees and listen to their tales of a new god and his queen, who kill from a distance with magic. Morgan examines the wound of one man who survived this "magic" attack and immediately recognizes his injuries as a bullet wound.

After briefly consulting with his daughter, the sorceress Jennifer Morgan, Travis Morgan goes off to scout ahead with his companion, the cat/woman Shakira. Also along for the ride is Tinder - a bard who serves in the Warlord's court, who is determined to get some new stories to tell.







On the road to Kiro, they stumble across a band of slavers. Warlord recognizes one of their captives as Machiste; king of Kiro and a long-time friend of Warlord. Tinder insists that they must go and warn the nearby villagers of the approaching slavers but Morgan will not abandon his friend for the sake of strangers. Tinder rides off alone to warn the peasants as Warlord and Shakira attack the slavers. They free Machiste, who tells Morgan that this new God and his Queen have kidnapped his wife - the swordswoman/archeologist Mariah.

In another part of the jungle, a wounded Tinder crosses paths with Alysha. The two save each others' lives - he by saving her from a dinosaur and she by tending his wounds after he collapses. The two trade stories, with Alysha saying that what is happening with the New God is all her fault for having brought him to Skartaris in the first place.







The three warriors agree to go after Tinder, before making further plans to fight this new God. They stumble across another group of refugees, who tell the them that Tinder saved them from the slavers, holding them off before being shot with an arrow and falling off a cliff. Not knowing that Tinder survived the fall, Morgan morns the loss of the idealistic young bard and vows to finish the battle he started.

Cut to The Shadow Lands, where we find that the New God and his Queen are - surprise! - Ned Hawkins and Kate Archer, who are using Mariah's talents as an archeologist to translate various writings in the hopes of gaining access to the near-magical technology of Atlantis. McBane is still here, filming the whole thing - now documenting Hawkins rise to be ruler of the world.







Morgan, Machiste and Shakira attack in this moment but are quickly overpowered by the magic Hawkins now wields. Shakira manages to shape-change into a cat and get away, while Morgan and Machiste are captured. Shakira finds Tinder and Alysha at nearby village and the three plot how to best rescue their friends.

With the help of McBane, who - witnessing the further madness of Hawkins and Archer - decides he can no longer just be a spectator, the three succeed in freeing Warlord and Machiste. Knowing they will need the weapons of Earth to counter Hawkins and his guns, Morgan plans to return to the surface world to get what they need as he sends Machiste to summon Tara and her armies.







A nice, rich story and one I suggest that you all read in full.

If the story can be said to be rich, then the artwork may put you diabetics out there into sugar shock. Both Joe Prado (artist on Issues 1, 2 and part of 4) and Chad Hardin (artist on Issues 3 and part of 4) do an amazing job depicting the rich vibrancy of Skartaris and the power contained within each character. Indeed, I didn't even notice that there was more than one artist working on the series until Issue 4 where both artists took separate parts of the story.

The book also features three inkers, for some reason, which may account for why some of the scenes appear to be darker than others. Still, considering that these scenes take place in the Shadow Lands or within a similarly dark setting, these differences can probably be written off as artistic differences and not stylistic clashes.

All in all, I would not only recommend this book to any fan of high fantasy, sword-and-sorcery comics - I would recommend it to anyone looking for a comic beyond the usual capes-and-tights stories. Be sure to get all four issues, though - you'll get into it a lot easier if you have all the chapters handy at once.

Green Lantern #43





The long awaited prologue to Blackest Night, this issue was not quite what I was expecting to kick off the summer's most long awaited storyline. Rather than an action-filled extravaganza, we are given a thoughtful character analysis of long-time Green Lantern villain Black Hand. This is reminiscent of Geoff Johns' similar stories centering upon Captain Cold and Heatwave in Flash #182 and Flash #218 respectively, both in subject matter (i.e. what makes this villain tick?) and in quality.



Some of the background we see here was seen in previous Johns'-penned Green Lantern stories such as Rebirth. No Fear and Secret Origins. The rest is explained clearly enough for new readers. The short version is that William Hand was the middle son of two undertakers and that he grew up obsessed with death from an early age. And when I say obsessed, I mean he stuffed the family pets because he liked them better dead.

That changed after he was introduced to the Green Lanterns, stole an alien device that allowed him to steal the energy from Green Lantern rings and eventually gained the power to drain life from living people. Which brings us here... as he returns to his boyhood home and is visited by the demented Guardian Scar, who gives William Hand the first Black Lantern Ring and declares him Herald and Embodiment of the Black Lantern Corps.





It would be easy for this story to focus upon the more lurid aspects of William Hand's nature and the revelation that he is (at the very least) a platonic necrophile. Doubtlessly many who read this story will criticize DC Comics and Johns in particular for revising a classic villain's motivations in this matter. This is folly, I believe, since Johns is very thoughtful in going about this revision and he truly delves into the psychosis behind the character of William Hand.

This creates something much deeper and intelligent than the various attempts at darkening villains made in the 1990s (Killer Moth? Make him a giant cannibal mothman! Next!) What is more impressive is that Johns is able to make Hand's romantic love of death clear without any lurid sexual details or even using the word necrophilia. Enough is implied for readers to draw their own conclusions, with the squeamish equally able to conclude that Hand's love of death stops at cuddling up to skeletons, sleeping in open graves and his first kiss coming from a corpse in a body bag.





The art by Doug Mahnke, Christian Alamy and Randy Major deserves praise too. Not only do they depict the truly disgusting and horrifying elements of this story but they manage the more subtle horrors inherit in its' creepy central setting of a secluded funeral home. Even the scenes of the Hand family having dinner together are filled with a barely-hidden veneer of civility where the sense that the spookiness will bleed through into the "real world" at any moment is palatable.

If you're been curious about Green Lantern and the hype train behind Blackest Night, this is the issue to jump on and enjoy the ride. All the references to past stories are explained away clearly in the text, so new readers should be able to get into it easily. We can only hope that the rest of the series can continue at this level of quality. Perhaps it will even find a way to exceed it. As the Blue Lanterns say, we can only hope.

Green Arrow/Black Canary #22

Fair Warning: I just skimmed through this in the comic shop, while I was waiting for the line to die down this morning on the way to work, so some of this may not be totally accurate. Feel free to let me know if I was off on any major plot details in the comments.



If you've been reading this blog and my writing for a while, you know that Green Arrow and Black Canary are two of my favorite characters and that I'm a little obsessive about seeing them written properly. You also might remember how I savaged the first issue of Andrew Kreisberg's run on this title, noting that he portrayed Black Canary as being an incompetent fighter AND incapable of controlling her super powers.

The following issues have gotten worse and worse and worse, with Dinah's personal history having been rewritten to become a blatant rip-off of the origin of Rogue from X-Men (i.e. discovers powers by accident, nearly kills classmate). What is worse than that is that Dinah is being written more and more out of character, proving to be both incompetent in battle AND inexplicably jealous of the crazed killer who is stalking her husband.

This issue? Well, it looks Kreisberg has heard the fan complaints about how horribly out of character Dinah has been acting in his work and has responded by trying to turn Dinah into a completely unsympathetic bitch, hoping that the readers will come to be as indifferent towards Dinah as he is.

A bold statement? Damn right it is. But what else can we conclude from the text we are given?

How else do you explain why the comic ends with Dinah ordering Ollie to stop being Green Arrow, saying he is getting too close to the fire? This statement being made regarding how Ollie apparently did nothing after Stupid.. er, I mean Cupid (a.k.a. The crazed redhead hottie stalking Ollie) killed another murderer - a man who stabbed his out of control girlfriend for no readily apparent reason - in the midst of the recent rioting?

Refresh my memory - wasn't Dinah chewing Ollie out a few months ago for admitting that he sometimes wanted to kill the violent killer super-villains he fought against. And now she's chewing him out for NOT giving into that urge with a violent killer super-villain, who just happens to be a gorgeous redhead who is after her man?

The whole scene not only makes Dinah look controlling and jealous (which makes no sense) but it also makes her look like a hypocritical bitch, seeing as how most of her half of the comic centers upon her dealing with the consequences of what happens when a hero loses control. In this case, Dinah losing control of her powers back in issue #15 deafened a young musician, who became inspired to build a device that could cure his deafness, instill deafness in others and release sonic blasts. Calls himself Discord.

Kreisberg does himself no favors here incidentally. He has Discord's younger brother show up and note that what Discord has built to fix his hearing could revolutionize the hearing-aid industry, asking why he is wasting such a thing on petty revenge when he could be healing the world. The answer, naturally, is a sonic blast which knocks said brother off the roof.

Here's a piece of free advice for you writers out there; the only time you should ever point out that a supervillain's technology could be more profitable being used for good than evil is when you are writing a comedic deconstruction of the genre (a.k.a. Patton Oswalt's JLA: Welcome to the Working Week) or when you are dealing with mercenary characters like Mirror Master, who are only in it for the cash and will happily play hero or villain for the right price.

What really takes the cake though, is the flashback sequences in which Kreisberg - apparently not content with ruining two characters- has to make Wildcat (Ted Grant) and the original Black Canary (Dinah Drake Lance) look foolish. Here's the quick outline of what has been happening in the flashbacks.


1. A young Dinah injures her best friend/crush when she discovers her powers as a teenager.

2. Dinah tells her mom what happens. Terrified and in tears, Dinah Sr. calls "a friend" and asks them to watch Dinah and see what they can find out.

3. Dinah Jr. realizes she is being followed, runs home, and is shocked when a man in a cat suit suddenly jumps through the kitchen window.

4. Dinah Sr. gives Ted Grant an earful, says he was just supposed to figure out if Dinah Jr. is a metahuman or not and then find a way to cure her.

5. It is at this point that Dinah Jr. finds out that Dinah Sr. was The Black Canary and was a member of the JSA back in the day. She apparently retired to be a stay-home mom.

6. Ted Grant talks to Dinah Jr. in the backyard and says he can teach her out to fight and maybe learn the control she needs. He has this talk, with Dinah Sr. standing on the back porch, apparently watching everything.


It's pretty well established - in multiple sources - that Dinah Jr. grew up knowing who her mom was and having all the other JSA members as adopted uncles. This whole sequence pretty much confirms what we've long suspected - Kreisberg hasn't read one issue of Birds of Prey, much less the flashback issue there which showed that Dinah Sr. was an active heroine for a good long while and that Dinah Jr. was long aware of her mom's double life, to the point of staying up all night worrying and fixing breakfast for her superhero mom and detective dad as they got home from their late-night jobs.

But even if we ignore the history and continuity issues that only scholars like me are likely to know or care about, how do you explain away...

1. Why is Dinah Sr. terrified of the possibility that her daughter is a metahuman? This isn't Marvel, for crying out loud!

2. Out of all the people she knew who could figure out if her daughter is a metahuman (Dr. Midnite is a medical doctor, Hourman is a pharmacologist, Starman is a scientist, etc), why did she call the professional boxer who dresses like a cat?

3. For that matter, you'd expect Ted Grant to have more common sense than to wear his costume when he's supposed to be observing someone unseen.

4. You'd also expect Ted to have better sense than to jump through a friend's kitchen window, breaking the glass, just to show off.

5. I don't like the idea that Dinah Sr. gave up heroing just to be a stay at home mom. Didn't even run the Floral shop as a side business, it seems. Hardly seems like the actions of a woman who would become a superheroine in the first place.

6. I REALLY don't like how the decision to become a superheroine seems to have been suggested to Dinah Jr. by Ted, rather than it being her idea before she went to Ted begging for training behind the back of her disapproving mother. Again, I skimmed... but that's I think the book played out.

I really need to stop glancing through this book. It does me no good and I think I'm preaching to the choir at this point about how this comic sucks.



EDIT NOTE: I forgot to mention this as I was trying to remember the story writing the above, but in the last splash panel depicting Dinah - no longer depressed as she was a relative page earlier at the revelation that she inspired a super-villain to villainy - is jumping over the rooftops in triumph...

... with the front of her costume clearly unzipped. Seriously, the ring to her zipper is right there around her cleavage!









EDIT TO THE EDIT NOTE: Thanks to innerbrat for scanning this for me.

Conan The Cimmerian #11


This issue is what we call a bridge comic - it doesn't have much purpose other than to provide us with exposition, character moments and link major plot points together. This sort of comic is fairly common with any story written in the Decompressed style a.k.a. Writing For The Trade. It's fairly common to see this sort of thing in chatty, wordy comics like Starman, the later story arcs of Sandman and pretty much everything ever written by Brian Michael Bendis. It is fairly rare to see it in a comic like Conan.

There are several reasons for this, the main one being that the action-based focus of most fantasy stories, set as they are in worlds where life is cheap and every day a struggle, leaves little time for introspection. Besides, who wants to see Gorak The Destroyer waxing philosophical over a campfire when he could be slashing demons to ribbons and throwing wide-hipped maidens over his hefty shoulder as he flees The Temple of The Unspeakable Nine-Eyed Goat God? Even those of us who know Conan, as a character, to have a certain crude eloquence that lends itself well to the speaking of insults if not the honeyed-words of poets wooing women, do not expect a lot of talking in your average Conan story.

In the case of Brian Reed on Red Sonja, which I reviewed earlier this week, we know what he is doing. Like a poor stage magician, we see how he gestures one way with his hand in order to distract us from what he is doing with the other. But he cannot hide the flowers up his sleeve. He is trying to tell an epic fantasy tale about the quest for a magic talisman but we cannot help but notice that the tale is delayed with the description of action we have already seen and flashbacks to the conclusion of fights that are not seen in their entirety.

Tim Truman on Conan, on the other hand, is a master magician who takes a trick that we have seen many times before and makes it seem new.

This book is the fourth part of an adaptation of the classic Robert E. Howard Conan story The Black Colossus (available for free on-line at the preceding link) and it is a credit to Truman's talent as a writer that he is able to create this comic out of what amounts to one chapter of Howard's original work or four pages of text in the print edition. And yet, because of the way it is shown - with Truman's original dialogue and descriptions adding detail to various passages, like the depravities committed by the dark mage Natohk - it seems very much like a new Conan story even to those of us who know well how the tale will end.








The art by artist Tomas Giorello and colorist Jose Villarrubia also deserve praise for fully bringing the world of Robert Howard's Hyboria to life. Giorello's light pencils mixed with Villarrubia's bold colors and deep shadows creates the feeling of a woodcut painted over. This further adds to the feeling that what we read is true history and no mere comic.

There is not much in the way of action or excitement in this issue as it sets up the final battle, with Conan now a general leading an unwilling army, the princess who both fears and lusts for the young barbarian insisting on coming along for the ride and Conan running into an old comrade from his days as a thief, whom provides the info dump of just how ancient and horrible the evils our heroes face truly are.

Still, it is to Truman's credit that the new reader could - in theory - pick this book up and read through it without being terribly confused. I would still suggest that anyone wishing to try Conan for the first time start with Issue #8 rather than this one but all in all, it is a serviceable issue for what it is - an adaptation of the one slow chapter of a classic sword-and-sorcery story.

Monday, July 6, 2009

Power Girl #2



This book goes over the top. And in doing so, it lets us know just where The Top is so we know where to go from there. Because as much sheer crazy wackiness as there is - even in the face of Power Girl being on the verge of dissection for most of the issue - there are many other things that are admirable in this book.

I admire how among all of Karen's employees, it is Donna - the one woman we see - who is willing to brave the attacks outside for the sake of getting to her loved ones.

I admire how Karen never gives up, never stops believing in herself and never stops TRYING to escape through the issue. None of this "I'm doomed!" B.S. or "Alas, poor me!" crap. Not even so much as a "Who will take care of Streaky when I'm gone?" Her one thought as doom approaches? "I have to get out of this... There has to be a way!"

I admire how Amanada Conner is able to make Kara look powerful and sexy while still capturing the inherent humor and drama of the story, making things consistent even as she moves between comedic and tragic scenes.

Yes, the sheer insanity of a mad scientist whose brain is in a giant white gorilla, demanding a superheroine surrender her body or else he will destroy New York City is a bit silly. Then again, you're expecting a mad scientist who put his brain inside the body of a giant white gorilla to be rational and make sense all of the time? I admire that too, because it is an utterly goofy premise and the Ultra Humanite is a very goofy character. And this book embraces that and plays it to the hilt.

Yes, the revelation that Ultra Humanite had a sexual relationship with Satanna once he was IN his giant ape-form (soaked in blood, no-less) is disgusting. But it's no more outrageous than the similar relationship between Gorilla Grodd and a female scientist or Gorilla Grodd and Giganta that was depicted in the Justice League cartoon. It all happens off camera and is played totally for laughs. And amazingly, it was played in completely and totally clean, in the same way as those Justice League episodes - without the S-E-X word being used and the comedy coming from the "ewww... gross" reaction of everyone else. And I admire that little touch - even though this book isn't aiming to be Approved By The Comics Code Authority by any stretch of the imagination.

But mostly, I admire how in an ever-darkening market, where character death is becoming more and more commonplace and cheap story gimmicks more frequent that this book - much like PG herself - is what it is, with no apologies for what it is not.

It is a fun read. And it is not ashamed of that, nor should it be.