Tuesday, September 15, 2009

An Ode To Alexandra DeWitt. Or Why Ron Marz Might Not Be Quite As Big A Pig As You Think.

I was catching up on When Fangirls Attack this afternoon, when I read an article by one Marron regarding Kyle Rayner's first love and the inspiration for the phrase Women In Refrigerators, Alexandra "Alex" DeWitt.

It's a good read. There's a few factual errors (Alex and Kyle weren't on their first date in Green Lantern #48 and Major Force had always been depicted as being relatively immortal) but these are things only a die-hard Green Lantern fan is likely to know. And ultimately these mistakes are unimportant compared to the main point of the article, which is made wonderfully. That is to say, to quote Marron, "Brutality against women in comic books is not acceptable as a plot device, especially when the character in question was created with no purpose other than being murdered."

Marron's main point is that, in creating a character whose death would forever change Kyle Rayner and force him to manhood/maturity as he took his first steps on The Hero's Path, there is no reason why the death had to be that of a female character. Alex could have easily been a man and the death need not have been that of Kyle's girlfriend but his brother, father, uncle or best friend.

Now, this is a fair complaint, if only because the male hero avenging his wife/girlfriend/mother/sister/daughter is probably the biggest cliche in the action/adventure genre. But I think it's also a little unfair to draw major conclusions about Ron Marz's feminist credentials (or lack thereof) based on one character in one story. Particularly given that he managed a hell of a feat with Alex DeWitt given what he had to work with... but I'm getting ahead of myself.

In her article, Marron quotes from a statement Ron Marz made to Gail Simone's website about Alex Dewitt. Marz said, in defense of Alex's death, that "Alex was a character destined to die from the moment she was first introduced in GL #48. I created her with the intention of having her be murdered at the hands of Major Force."

While this does seem like a damning statement at first, the rest of the paragraph does, in my mind, absolves Ron Marz of some of the flack he has gotten. For while he did create Alex solely for the purpose of killing her off, he did realize how important her death needed to be and what that required of him as a writer.

" I took a lot of care in building her as a character, because I wanted her to be liked and her death to mean something to the readers. I wanted readers to be horrified at the crime, and to empathize with Kyle's loss."

It would have been easy for Marz to make Alex a one-note character... but he didn't. He made Alex smart. He made Alex funny. He made Alex, in a lot of ways, a much more stable and likable person than Kyle. And he did this in just three issues.

Just think about that. Three issues.

Three issues he has to develop this character who many readers fell in love with instantly... just to kill her off so the audience would get good and pissed off at the bad guy. Given that it's some 15 years or so after that story and people are still talking about it and still pissed off about how Alex died - I'd say that Ron Marz accomplished his goal with the story.

Yes, Alex DeWitt's death was tragic. It was stupid and pointless. But it would have been stupid and pointless regardless of whether Alex had was a man or a woman. So whatever else you may say about Ron Marz, I don't think you can call him a bad writer. He accomplished his goal with Alex DeWitt and created a character who we were genuinely sorry to see die. And I find it hard to level charges of sexism against a man who concluded his thoughts on Alex DeWitt's death with these words.

"Comics have a long history as a male-oriented and male-dominated industry. That's not a statement of judgment, simply one of fact. I do think comics can and should be more sensitive to female characters. But these are times in which the general editorial mindset is "cut to the fight scene," in which half-naked women on covers spike sales. Publishers are unfortunately more concerned with survival than with sensitivity to women. And that's a shame. If we want to save our industry, maybe we should stop ignoring half the population as possible readers."

It's funny what prompted me to think about this was another remark about Alex. How "the only way Alex DeWitt is coming back is possibly as a Black Lantern in Geoff Johns’ Blackest Night event. Sadly, I don't think we're going to get even that which is a shame as I always liked Alex better than Donna Troy or Jade. And I can't believe this malarkey we're getting now about Jade being Kyle's One True Love.

Read Green Lantern/Green Lantern #1 from the Circle of Fire mini-series. That's all I'm saying.









Good night, Ms. DeWitt. Wherever you are.

Help out Aerie of Queen of Wands and Punch and Pie!

http://community.livejournal.com/punch_an_pie/130146.html

I know some of you are fans of her comics, so if you can afford to PayPal a few bucks her way, do so.

Monday, September 14, 2009

Nearly Everything I've Read In Steptember... So Far.

Okay. So more budget problems kept me from getting my comics for a week. And then crummy weather kept me from getting them until the Sunday after I got paid. So here's what I don't feel like writing separate special reviews for.



BARACK THE BARBARIAN #2 - A bit of a let down after the first issue. Not that it's bad by any means... but the artist is not a good caricaturist and only the punny names help us identify some of the foul Pond Ditz er, I mean pundits who inhabit the labyrinth. Billo and Limbo as Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum is inspired but the helpful pundit "Rake Hell" doesn't look a blessed thing like her inspiration. No "Mad Doe The Barbarian Princess"? For shame, Larry Hama!


DOCTOR WHO #3 - Apart from wondering just how the main big bad of the story survived his last appearance on the show, this is a very effective issue of the comic you could easily see being an episode of the TV series. The short version is that The Doctor is put on trial for interfering with the space-time continuum and playing God with the universe. The fact that the laws he's violated were set down by the now-dead Time Lords and the fact that he was acting for the greater good aren't worth a tinker's cuss, especially with the prosecutor for the trial being another would-be universe conqueror who the Doctor stopped once before. Throw in a few attempts to see The Doctor assassinated before, during and after his trial and you've got a heck of a story to lead us into next issue...


RED SONJA #48 - Nothing much happens for another issue, with people still refusing to talk about their mysterious, ill-defined plans as they continue to move northward towards their vaguely defined and rather pointless goal, since we now know the weapon everybody was searching for was Red Sonja herself. And it turns out the place the bad guy was searching for was the resting place of Sonja's mostly-dead patron goddess, who wants him to save her from Sonja, who she is convinced is coming to kill her off.

I'd quit now but then I'd always be left wondering just how the hell all this randomness will come together. At least the scene with Sonja fighting werewolves, brief though it is, is decent.


WARLORD #6 - Everything gets tired up in a neat little package, though I'm a little amazed at just how quickly archeologist turned fur bikini babe Alysha has become a competent warrior. Still, I can swing with it simply because this issue is almost all action and is entirely awesome. And the ending promises the return of an old enemy as the series continues...



Tomorrow: The latest on Blackest Night. Also Six Things To Love In Secret Six. And Wonder Woman (finally!)

The Birth of a Meme

In response to this and this, I have created this...







Comic Reviews Will Be Posted Tomorrow. I promise!

Monday, August 31, 2009

Thoughts on Blackest Night August Releases



BLACKEST NIGHT: BATMAN #1 - Quite a few clues dropped here, as whatever is animating the dead superheroes is doing it without their souls/spirits/whatever Deadman is, as we see Deadman attempting to possess his own zombified body. And the interplay between Dick and Damien as the new Batman and Robin is nice for those of us who haven't been reading the Bat Books.

My one quibble with the set-up, as numerous dead Batman villains are resurrected over Gotham in-route to The Hall of Justice? I can understand wanting to keep the remains of dangerous metahumans like KGBeast hidden away from graverobbers seeking superhuman organs for transplant... but who the hell is going to want to steal the body of The Ventriloquist? It's not like he had superhuman vocal cords. At least, I don't think he did. But even if he did, how useful would that be?


BLACKEST NIGHT: SUPERMAN #1 -Now, THIS is the James Robinson we know and love. Though I'm a little confused as to why the Zombie Earth 2 Lois and Kal-L are harassing Ma Kent and Smallville as opposed to Power Girl and all of the New Krypton stuff with Supergirl was lost on me, this was still a good read if somewhat inaccessible. The coolest part? Unlike everyone else we've seen so far, Superman seems to radiate multiple emotional energies at once - at one point being a rainbow of Rage, Fear, Will, Hope and Love.


BLACKEST NIGHT: TITANS #1 - I'll admit to not being the greatest Titans scholar but a lot of the characterization in this one seemed off to me. Most of the issue features the current team of Titans and Teen Titans mourning/honoring the dead. A fight breaks out between Beast Boy and Cyborg/Starfire over why Terra has a statue when she was a traitor and why GeoForce mourns her. You'd think this issue would have been raised BEFORE the statue was put up in their Hall Of The Fallen or that at the very least Vic would - as Gar's best friend - be a little more tactful about dissing the guy's ex-girlfriend when Gar is feeling blue.

Given that, it's hard for me not to be rooting for the zombies in this one, especially since Lilith has returned. Lilith, you might remember, got royally shafted when she got killed, as it happened just before Donna Troy died(again) and everybody was too busy talking about how great Donna was to remember - oh, yeah... we lost another teammate too! And full creepy props for Donna Troy's son returning in a spectral baby carriage, even though I'm pretty sure he was out of diapers when he died.


BLACKEST NIGHT #2 - If you had told me a year ago that the best comic series I'd read all year would feature a scene where Aquaman comes back from the dead and starts killing his family, I'd have called you a damn liar. But damn me if that whole sequence isn't kind of awesome.

In fact, all the awesome action scenes - like where The Spectre himself is corrupted by The Black Power or where Barry Allen uses basic chemistry to take down a zombified Martian Manhunter - are eclipsed only by the nice little character touches, like Jim Gordon slyly talking about Batgirl as if she were a different person while talking to Barbara, because neither can be sure who is listening at that moment.


GREEN LANTERN CORPS #39 - Quite a lot of stuff here involving on-going plots. All of it pretty good. To sum up...

* When put under the influence of a Star Sapphire beam that was supposed to reveal his one true love, Kyle lied about who he saw as his true love. It was, in fact, dead girlfriend Jade rather than current girlfriend Soranik. Personally, I'm disappointed it wasn't Kyle's original dead girlfriend Alex. I'm also disappointed that we apparently won't see her in this storyline because bringing back the original Woman In A Refrigerator as a vengeful zombie would be awesome on so many levels.

* Guy, not surprisingly, radiates Rage rather than Will in a fight, even when using his ring.

* Arissa abandons Daxam to it's fate, cursing the death of her partner, Sodam Yat and how he sacrificed himself to save a world full of racist xenophobes who weren't worth saving.

* Mongul continues his coup of the Sinestro Corps.

* Everyone in the Green Lantern Corps crypts on Oa comes back. Hilarity ensues.


GREEN LANTERN #45 - This issue is wall-to-wall fighting. And thank goodness for it!

* The entire dead planet of Xanshi returns from the dead - as a big black ball with the Black Hand symbol on it, ala Mogo.

* Carol Ferris fights Sinestro, as the Loyal Sinestro Corps followers assault Zamoran, for what the Star Sapphires did/tried doing to convert many of their members into soldiers of Love. Then they get surrounded by Black Lanterns, recruited from the ranks of dead Sinestro Corps Members.

* Several Green Lanterns fight the Red Lanterns, on the Red Lantern base-world of Ysmault, only for both groups to be besieged by Black Lanterns, formed from the ranks of those killed by the Red Lanterns.

* The Orange Lantern assault on the Blue Lanterns ends, after Larfleeze is attacked by an army of Black Lanterns made up of... everyone he killed to create the Orange Lantern Corps.

* And in the middle of all this, everyone waits for the Indigo Power to show up...